SUMMARY


The City Centre Urban
Design Strategy (CCUDS)
explores the character of the
streets, spaces and buildings
in Leeds City Centre. It is a
response to national and local
policies and initiatives to
enhance the local distinctiveness
of our towns and cities.

Click here to enlarge

Click here to enlarge

_____________________________________
CCUDS exhibitions have been on display in the Planning and Building Centre at
the outset of the process in 1997/8
and more recently at the Victoria
Quarter during Urban Design Week
(September 1999). Workshops were
held focusing on CCUDS in October
1998 and February 1999.

 

Who for?

The aim of CCUDS is to provide a working tool which can be used to encourage good distinctive design proposals appropriate to Leeds City Centre. It is expected that CCUDS will be used by architects, planners, landscape architects, engineers, artists, surveyors, developers, interest groups and members of the public.

Who by?

This document has been produced in partnership, involving an inter-departmental/multi-disciplinary team and a number of key local consultees. Local professional and interest groups such as, Leeds Architecture and Design Initiative, Advisory Design Forum, Leeds Civic Trust, Chamber of Commerce, Victorian Society (West Yorkshire Group) and the Urban Design Alliance (Yorkshire Region) have been consulted and some were actively involved.

What is the approach?

The approach has involved a cyclical process including audit, analysis and aspirations. This process has been continuous throughout each stage of CCUDS (City Centre-wide, Study Areas, and Synthesis/Strategy).
The document contains three types of work :

City Centre-wide - Strategic maps (eg. gateways, tall buildings, landmarks and views), photos and sketch examples of themes and issues, written policy and urban design principles

Study Areas - Detailed urban design maps with photographs, particular urban design issues, based on analysis by variety of participants and inter-disciplinary workshop groups

Case Studies - Some examples of good practice to test and explain the principles established, varied scale of intervention into the existing cityscape (from guardrail design to building extensions and larger site development).

How is CCUDS to be used?

It is expected that the document will be used in a variety of ways, ranging from gathering general information about urban design issues in Leeds City Centre to exploring development opportunities for particular sites.


City Centre-wide

The City Centre-wide audit and analysis, which are central to the CCUDS approach, have been based on the themes of form, movement, space and use.
Possible aspirations have been implied in this broad approach, which builds on existing Council policies and initiatives affecting the City Centre (particularly the Unitary Development Plan (modified RDUDP), the Transport Strategy and the Millennium bid). A summary of urban design principles, based on the distinctive qualities of Leeds City Centre, has been established (and reproduced at the end of this summary).

Examples of some of the distinctive qualities the analysis has identified are illustrated in this document and include the following :

Clck here to enlarge
___________________________
A key characteristic of Leeds
City Centre is it rich mix of
new and old architecture

Form (buildings and morphology)
  • The grid iron quality of some parts of the City Centre, with short block lengths, building lines at back of footway, provide both variety and choice for the pedestrian

  • The location, and general poor quality, of Leeds tall buildings

  • Key building design issues such as scale, materials, legibility, views and skyline are outlined to provide a broad picture what makes the forms of Leeds City Centre locally distinctive (including relationship of new to old architecture).

 

Movement (vehicles and pedestrians)
  • Gateway and corridors study develops the Millennium bid idea and celebrates 'entrances' to the City Centre by road, rail and even canal !

  • Transport Strategy (Department of Highways and Transportation) is set out with its 'protective collar' around the positive pedestrian links through the yards and arcades of the central retail area

  • Particular 'pinch' points for pedestrians are also identified. Links through the railway arches to the riverside and south Leeds are considered both characteristic of Leeds and in need of enhancement, particularly by increasing the number of opportunities

Space (types and landscape)
  • A very wide range of types of space is identified in the City Centre (from small and intimate yards and ginnels to grand civic squares)

  • The strong sense of enclosure of the streets is a result of the grid iron quality and building heights

  • Perceived need for green space and improved riverside should be explored in further work

  • Components that clutter or enhance the streetscene are also examined and railings are identified as a key characteristic of the City Centre

Use (activity and regeneration)
  • Activity nodes are set out for different land uses (office, residential, retail, riverside and mixed based on the Quarter's plan of the modified RDUDP)

  • The challenge of encouraging activity in the street and safety from crime by natural surveillance is identified. The advantages of mixed use planning, enabling live, work, shop, play, worship and care to be in the City Centre need to be explored and developed in further work

  • A study of active frontages demonstrates the potential for many more land uses to develop active frontages

  • New uses for old buildings and spaces are providing good accommodation for offices, housing, bars and contributing to the sustainable agenda.


Study Areas

The Study Area work has provided a deeper level of detail and explored the 'local distinctiveness' of individual parts of the City Centre.

The nine Study Areas are based on the Quarters of Leeds City Centre, set out in the modified RDUDP. These Quarters are implied by the predominant land use which currently exists, giving each area its unique character of buildings, spaces, movement patterns and development pressures.

The Study Area analyses comprise a detailed map produced using a standard urban design key (derived from consultation work and current good practice) and photographs indicating the main urban design characteristics of the area (based on themes of form, movement, space and land use). This has led to the emphasis of key urban design issues and aspirations for each area. The urban design principles established in the broader City Centre-wide part of the work are also important when considering development opportunities.

_____________________
1.                        Civic and
hospital

_____________________
4.                       Education
_____________________
7.                         Eastern/
Quarry Hill

_____________________
2.                     Retail and
entertainment

_____________________
5.                       Riverside
_____________________
8.                       Southern/
Motorway
______________________
3.                               Office
______________________
6.                     Noth street/
Clay Pit Lane

______________________
9.               Western / Little
Woodhouse / Kirstall

It is clear that 'local distinctiveness' is applicable at many different levels in Leeds City Centre, ranging from City Centre-wide to Study Areas and smaller character areas, possibly culminating in the individual street.
The processes of CCUDS have encouraged this analysis through the different levels. This has provided complementary information relating to existing strategic and detailed urban design policies and initiatives, and recommended further work (set out in the 'next steps').


_______________________________________

Detailed urban design maps explore issues
such as, landmarks, gateways, views,
building frontages, spaces, development
opportunities and movement patterns


Case Studies

Eight case studies are set out which express some of the urban design principles established in this document. These range from small scale intervention to larger master planning examples.

Click here to enlarge

_________________________
Leonardo extension

Guardrail - decorative design in Retail Quarter

Albion Street - improved street enclosure by adding floor to diminutive plinth building

Leonardo extension - positive corner / urban infill repair on vacant site (shown below)

Millennium Square - space for relaxation and activity on former surface car park site

Templar Street former Bus Station site - improve Vicar Lane streetscene, gateway image to Inner Ring road, public square, re-use appropriate existing buildings

Sweet Street site - key gateway image, quality tall building, lower street edge to Holbeck

Riverside - repair urban grain, improve connections, lively riverside, mixed land use

Southern/Motorways - larger area plan/strategy produced by workshop group to resolve the problem of the effect of the motorway on the City Centre.

Next Steps

In many ways CCUDS is the beginning of a process which will continue to provide audits, analyses and aspirations for the City Centre in an environment of constant change. The next steps should include:

  • Virtual Reality computer model

  • Strategies for tall buildings, riverside and trees

  • Studies of housing, mixed use and activity in the streets

  • Proposals for improved links to outer areas

  • Action plans for the nine Study Areas

  • Periodic reviews of maps and principles

Protection and enhancement of the distinctive characteristics of Leeds City Centre is taking the form of a range of measures and initiatives by Leeds City Council involving :

  • Promotion of urban design attributes (exhibitions, internet, workshops, annual awards)

  • Management of change (development control processes)

  • Investment in schemes and partnerships (especially capital projects, such as Millennium Square and grant initiatives).

 

Summary of urban design principles for CCUDS

  • Reinforce the positive qualities of
    character areas which contribute to
    their sense of place

  • Re-establish fine urban grain where
    appropriate

  • Provide for appropriate enclosure to
    streets and the containment of spaces

  • Protect and enhance diversity in
    facade style and materials to create
    visual interests

  • Encourage excellence in new design
    - proposals should possess
    consistency and attention to detail,
    and development opportunities
    should be explored in three
    dimensions showing the context

  • Establish distinctive gateways to
    celebrate entrances to the City Centre

  • Preserve and enhance the skyline
    and roofscape visible from the
    streets and spaces of Leeds
  • Optimise and develop landmarks and
    views to create visual interest and
    legibility, enabling orientation and a
    sense of place for people in Leeds

  • Generally discourage tall buildings
    in the central area, good design of
    appropriately located development
    or re-development will be considered

  • Ensure proposals respect views to
    existing landmark and distant vistas

  • Encourage high quality new
    design which contributes well to the
    existing wealth of styles from
    different eras

  • Ensure main entrances to buildings
    are from a street, park or square -
    encouraging activity

  • Enhance and strenghten the
    corners of streets
F       o       r       m
Click here to enlarge
 
  • Balance the management of
    traffic with opportunities for
    the improvement of the
    pedestrian environment

  • Improve quality and choice for
    the pedestrian in the City Centre,
    encourage continuity and quality
    of the links between the Quarters

  • Improve pedestrian connections
    with areas outside the City Centre
    (especially adjacent housing)

  • Improve the sequential views for
    people entering the city by train,
    bus, car, bicycle, boat or on foot
  • Improve access for disabled
    people to spaces and buildings
    with solutions which respect
    the character of Leeds
    City Centre

  • Improve the quality and design
    of places for car parking

  • Ensure car parks respect
    the strong edge of
    the street
Click here to enlarge
M  o  v  e  m  e  n  t
For all development projects it is important that a good brief emerges
and a good design team is essential (client, architect, landscape
architect, engineers, surveyors, planners, artists).

Engagement with the public and those who will use the development
is also an important part of the design process

The Urban Task Force (1999) considers that competitions
and development briefs are critical for 'procuring excellence'
(RIBA Competition Office can manage the process)
  • Encourage bespoke railings and
    boundary walls appropriate to adjacent buildings and spaces

  • Promote distinctive street
    furniture - responding to the
    character areas and the City Centre Street Style
S     p     a     c     e
Click here to enlarge
  • Protect, enhance and provide new
    spaces responding to the
    recognisable variety of ginnels,
    yards, arcades, streets, malls,
    squares, parks and riverside

  • Promote trees and landscaping appropriate to an area

  • Promote new and refurbished
    spaces which are suitable
    for people of different ages, gender,
    race and mobility

  • Promote public art to enhance spaces and buildings
  • Encourage innovative and attractive
    multi-use street furniture/signage
    to prevent clutter

  • Encourage community
    involvement in improvement to
    spaces and potentiel for public art

  • Co-ordinate traffic (and other)
    signage and minimise intrusion
    of posts and footways

  • Improve the appearance of surface
    car parks (possible re-development
    as buidings/spaces)
 

Click here to enlarge
U           s            e
  • Promote street design which
    creates vitality, encourages
    movement and natural
    surveillance

  • Develop a mixture of land uses at different times of a day and night.

  • Civic/community buildings shall
    be located adjacent or within
    squares/spaces preferably with
    main street views

  • Promote active frontages at
    ground floor

  • Protect and enhance the dominant
    and ancillary activities which
    contribute to a Quarter's character
  • Promote cultural development
    which enhances relationship
    with existing and new public
    spaces in the City Centre

  • Facilitate the appropriate re-use
    and conversion of old buildings
    and spaces

  • Promote sustainable development
    through land use and movement
    strategies, the form and location
    of buildings and spaces, and the
    choice of materials (refer to Sustainable Development Design Guide)

P  R  I  N  C  I  P  L  E  S

C i t y  C e n t r e - W i d e

 
______________________
Summary of Urban Design
Principles on page 64-65

S   U   M   M   A   R   Y

L e e d s     C i t y    C e n t r e
U r b a n  d e s i g n  S t r a t e g y